Su-24 shot down near Syrian/Turkish border

ImageForum for news and discussions on miltary aviation matters.

Forum rules
Image
Kuine
Scramble Junior
Scramble Junior
Posts: 214
Joined: 30 Jul 2014, 20:31

Re: Su-24 shot down near Syrian/Turkish border

Post by Kuine »

Gerard wrote:http://haber.dha.com.tr/newpics/news/25 ... 216062.mp4

This is supposed to be a recording of the warnings issued by the Turkish Air Force to the Russian Su-24.
Not very clearly readable, to say the least :roll:

Glad i'm not a pilot,i was shot down all the time with this kind of warnings..
WTF are they saying???
F17_114PM
Scramble Addict
Scramble Addict
Posts: 1246
Joined: 26 Nov 2006, 10:32
Subscriber Scramble: F17_114PM

Re: Su-24 shot down near Syrian/Turkish border

Post by F17_114PM »

hammarö wrote:Russia bombed today a rescue convoy at Azaz, Syria near Turkey border. The rescue convoy send food pointed to refugees. At least seven dead and ten wounded.

http://www.aftonbladet.se/nyheter/utrik ... 1832419.ab
Now, that´s almost funny ... Here you cann clearly see how news are beeing manipulated in one or another country.
In the german News, they said, that this particular convoy was transporting building material and weapons to the Turkmens in northern Syria.
Whom should we now believe ... the swedish or the germans ...; I guess better nobody ...

P.S.: Ehusmann, I understand your position, but I can not agree with you in the total ;)
BirdieBarty
Scramble Senior
Scramble Senior
Posts: 331
Joined: 03 Jul 2015, 14:01
Type of spotter: MIL
Subscriber Scramble: YES
Location: Castricum

Re: Su-24 shot down near Syrian/Turkish border

Post by BirdieBarty »

Just lovely to read all these different messages here.
I´m a militair myself... in or out Syria... everybody knows it´s a war zone there. Besides many of these comments are based on media speculation.
Truth is... a plane got shot down after multiple warnings in a war zone... end of story.
You guys complaining now about the higher gas rates now Russia closes down the pipes.
Kuine
Scramble Junior
Scramble Junior
Posts: 214
Joined: 30 Jul 2014, 20:31

Re: Su-24 shot down near Syrian/Turkish border

Post by Kuine »

Russia is considering the possibility of sending 10-12 more fighter aircraft to the Hmeymim Air Base in Syria to ensure cover for each of its 24 bombers, the Russian Kommersant newspaper reports citing a military source.

Read more: http://sputniknews.com/military/2015112 ... z3saDwcx2F
BlackBird
Scramble Senior
Scramble Senior
Posts: 262
Joined: 07 Apr 2006, 12:36
Subscriber Scramble: BlackBird
Location: ZHZ

Re: Su-24 shot down near Syrian/Turkish border

Post by BlackBird »

The first casualty when war comes is truth
US Senator Hiram Warren Johnson (1918).

Since then, nothting has changed
User avatar
Gerard
Scramble Master
Scramble Master
Posts: 3941
Joined: 25 Feb 2007, 20:00
Subscriber Scramble: Jawohl
Location: 9.9NM NE of Büdingen AAF (closed)

Re: Su-24 shot down near Syrian/Turkish border

Post by Gerard »

Kuine wrote:
Gerard wrote:http://haber.dha.com.tr/newpics/news/25 ... 216062.mp4

This is supposed to be a recording of the warnings issued by the Turkish Air Force to the Russian Su-24.
Not very clearly readable, to say the least :roll:
Glad i'm not a pilot,i was shot down all the time with this kind of warnings..
WTF are they saying???
Well, at around 0:50 I can identify:
"This is Turkish Air Force speaking on guard, you are approaching Turkish territory, change your heading south immediately", but the rest, except for a few repetitions of this sentence, :?: :?: :?: :?: :?:
.          |
          /O\
\_______[|(.)|]_______/
  o   ++   O   ++   o
Agfaritsrats
Scramble Junior
Scramble Junior
Posts: 206
Joined: 21 Jun 2007, 12:10

Re: Su-24 shot down near Syrian/Turkish border

Post by Agfaritsrats »

"Success has many fathers, but failure is an orphan" and "truth differs upon perspective".
The Turk AF AIM-9 seems to have struck the Su-24 while over Syria. (Not denied by any party afaik.) The Fencer pilot said they never knew what hit them (? Su's not having missile warning indicators?) But, did Turkey, by firing into Syria, in turn violate Syrian airspace?
Turk. AF did fly over Iraq on many occasions against Kurd PKK, but (afaik) was never attacked by Iraqi AA / AF (so far).
If this Su-24 was not shot down deliberately as ordered by its fighter controllers, you can always have systems go down, or people making errors or even failing to comply with the Rules of Engagements. Like the AC-130 Spectre crew and coordinators in a recent attack (everything went wrong (they claim) striking the wrong 'safe' place). Several US forces individuals are now suspended and are pending sanctions or mil.court, statement US yesterday. VID & DETAILS: KLIK HERE
KPN's Hi-prepaid = beltegoed-jatters.
User avatar
De Verrekieker
Scramble Die-Hard
Scramble Die-Hard
Posts: 702
Joined: 01 Jan 2006, 18:01
Type of spotter: Allround
Subscriber Scramble: Indeed
Location: Purmerend, 75 KM from NAS De Kooy
Contact:

Re: Su-24 shot down near Syrian/Turkish border

Post by De Verrekieker »

Also Novosibirisk Tolmachevo. Here is ... /VVS 2015.

hI Hammaro, here are some updates.

213yellow is the RF-95586 (8AMTS00643137384U)
214yellow is the RF-95587 (8AMTS00643137385U)
221yellow is the RF-95588 (8AMTS00643137386U)
222yellow is the RF-95589 (8AMTS00643137387U)
231yellow is the RF-95592 (8AMTS00643137401U)
233yellow is the RF-95594 (8AMTS00643137402U)
241yellow only RF- (8AMTS00643137404U)
244yellow is the RF-95599 (8AMTS00643137407U)
253yellow is the RF-95602 (8AMTS00643137410U)
254yellow only RF- (8AMTS00643137411U)

All 562AvB AA

Greetz.
hammarö
Scramble Addict
Scramble Addict
Posts: 1591
Joined: 19 Jun 2012, 10:30
Type of spotter: I am not Dutch fluent.
Subscriber Scramble: hammarö

Re: Su-24 shot down near Syrian/Turkish border

Post by hammarö »

Great Verrekleker.
atla
Scramble Junior
Scramble Junior
Posts: 124
Joined: 20 Feb 2008, 22:41
Subscriber Scramble: atla

Re: Su-24 shot down near Syrian/Turkish border

Post by atla »

The Turkish warned the plane ten times in five minutes... yeah right... :mrgreen:

http://motherboard.vice.com/read/belgia ... ussian-jet
User avatar
ehusmann
Scramble Master
Scramble Master
Posts: 6090
Joined: 03 Aug 2005, 14:34
Location: Loures, Portugal

Re: Su-24 shot down near Syrian/Turkish border

Post by ehusmann »

Hmm, bad scientists. If I look at the map, it looks like the aircraft crossed the same area of Turkey twice. This is also what I read from an earlier statement (please correct me if not the case). If you take the 980 km/h, that is 272 m/s. 2km is travelled in 7.3 seconds, but in 8.5 seconds you travel 2.3 km. 2.3km is still about 2km (they do not give the exact distance). And if the jet indeed crossed twice, it indeed spent 17 seconds in Turkish airspace. So, the Turkish statement would be correct.

Furthermore, if they started warning the plane already before the first crossing (which is perfectly likely) and again before the second, then the 5 minutes is not weird either. Not for 5 minutes straight, but in a timespan of a few minutes, which most people would describe as 5 minutes as it is the smallest number of minutes usually used to describe a short timeframe.

So if the assumption that the jet crossed Turkey twice is correct, then the Turkish side of the story actually checks out and the scientist made a fool of themselves...

Erwin
Image
User avatar
Slijfie
Scramble Die-Hard
Scramble Die-Hard
Posts: 782
Joined: 23 Sep 2002, 13:14
Subscriber Scramble: Slijfie
Location: Hillegom
Contact:

Re: Su-24 shot down near Syrian/Turkish border

Post by Slijfie »

ehusmann wrote:... If you take the 980 km/h, that is 272 m/s. 2km is travelled in 7.3 seconds...
What puzzles me: in the video you can see the wings of the Sukhoi in the forward position. When flying 980 km/h? At what speed do they fold the wings?
User avatar
Gerard
Scramble Master
Scramble Master
Posts: 3941
Joined: 25 Feb 2007, 20:00
Subscriber Scramble: Jawohl
Location: 9.9NM NE of Büdingen AAF (closed)

Re: Su-24 shot down near Syrian/Turkish border

Post by Gerard »

Slijfie wrote:What puzzles me: in the video you can see the wings of the Sukhoi in the forward position. When flying 980 km/h? At what speed do they fold the wings?
The aircraft most probably has no hydraulic pressure anymore. Maybe that causes the wings to move forward :?:
.          |
          /O\
\_______[|(.)|]_______/
  o   ++   O   ++   o
FredL
Scramble Die-Hard
Scramble Die-Hard
Posts: 536
Joined: 27 Aug 2012, 22:21

Re: Su-24 shot down near Syrian/Turkish border

Post by FredL »

Lucky Turkish Top guns !!
What a chance the F-16Cs were just right there at the very right moment during those (alleged, still not proven) 2 x 7 seconds (or unique few seconds) lasting air space violation(s) and, after the (also alleged) 10 warnings, managed to
1. put themself in firing position,
2. then get an AIM-9 lock on,
3. and finally fire the sidewinder on this Su-24 which was probably already quite far, out of Turkish air.

Comic books hero "Lucky Lucke" usually manages to do that ; shooting faster then his own shadow.
If some people were not dead, I would conclude with this humour point.
But regarding the situation it is just sensless, :!:

Or maybe we all would beter wait until more information emerge (if it does one day...). I guess there are just too many hypotheses and speculations while almost nothing proven, from both sides, right now.
Fishbed_9307
Scramble Die-Hard
Scramble Die-Hard
Posts: 640
Joined: 07 Mar 2014, 17:25

Re: Su-24 shot down near Syrian/Turkish border

Post by Fishbed_9307 »

FredL wrote:Lucky Turkish Top guns !!
What a chance the F-16Cs were just right there at the very right moment during those (alleged, still not proven) 2 x 7 seconds (or unique few seconds) lasting air space violation(s) and, after the (also alleged) 10 warnings, managed to
1. put themself in firing position,
2. then get an AIM-9 lock on,
3. and finally fire the sidewinder on this Su-24 which was probably already quite far, out of Turkish air.

Comic books hero "Lucky Lucke" usually manages to do that ; shooting faster then his own shadow.
If some people were not dead, I would conclude with this humour point.
But regarding the situation it is just sensless, :!:

Or maybe we all would beter wait until more information emerge (if it does one day...). I guess there are just too many hypotheses and speculations while almost nothing proven, from both sides, right now.
Apparently there is another way to solve this kind of incursions: http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/204072

As you suggest FredL; the Turks appear to be extremely trigger happy and one might wonder on which side they really are.

Regards, Paul
Post Reply

Return to “Military Aviation News”